Originals only · Collector-grade listings
Buy, sell & trade original retro games.
Carts, discs and consoles from real collectors — graded the way collectors talk. Sell yours for 8% + 30¢, or trade in with Jay's for store credit.
Originals only
Reproductions are banned. Repro boxes and manuals must be disclosed.
Lowest fees
New sellers pay 0% on their first $100. Then 8% + 30¢ — no listing or buyer fees.
Protected payments
Sellers are paid only after you confirm delivery (or 14 days after tracking). Claims freeze payouts.
Shop by platform
Pick your console
Collectibles
Cards, Pops, plush & movies
Just listed
Fresh arrivals
Sell it yourself
Set your price. Keep ~92%.
List in a few minutes with photos and your own selling points. Buyers pay through Stripe; you ship with tracking and get paid straight to your bank.
Seller fees on a $40 game + $5 shipping
- Jay's Retro Exchange$3.50
- Mercari (+$1.62 from buyer)$4.50
- eBay$6.52
Competitor fees as published, Sep 2026, before sales tax.
Sell to Jay's
Trade in, skip the listing.
Get up to 70% of market value in store credit. Send us your list, get an itemized offer locked for 14 days, and ship free on $50+ or drop off in store.
| Market value | Cash | Credit |
|---|---|---|
| $5 – $49.99 | 45% | 60% |
| $50 – $249.99 | 50% | 65% |
| $250+ | 55% | 70% |
| Working consoles | 45% | 60% |
How it works
Collector-grade, start to finish
Listings that say it all
Completeness, grade, label and disc condition, region, save battery and mods — every listing, every time.
Condition guide →Repro-free marketplace
Reproduction carts are banned and reported listings are reviewed by staff. Buyers get 30 days to flag a fake.
Reproduction policy →Paid after it ships
Sellers are paid only after you confirm the package arrived (or 14 days after tracking if you don't respond) — so a no-show seller never gets your money.
Buyer protection →Reviews
What collectors say about Jay's
—
0 reviews
- 5 star0
- 4 star0
- 3 star0
- 2 star0
- 1 star0
Be the first to review Jay's.
Bought from Jay's, traded in or had discs resurfaced? Tell other collectors how it went — it takes a minute.