Retro games
NES · SNES · N64
Game Boy · PS1 / PS2
Dreamcast · GameCube
Buy • Sell • Trade • Restore
Jay's Retro Exchange
Turn your collection into cash or digital store credit.
01 — Inventory
What we buy
If it's on this list, bring it in. If it isn't, ask anyway — we look at most things once, and we'll tell you straight if it isn't something we can move.
Current gen
PS5 · Xbox Series
Switch · Switch 2
Discs, carts, accessories
Pokémon
Singles · Bulk lots
Sealed product
Vintage through modern
Plush
Build-A-Bear
Ty / Beanie Babies
Tagged and untagged
Physical media
Collectible VHS
Out-of-print DVDs
Box sets and slipcovers
Hardware
Consoles · Controllers
Cables · Memory cards
Accessories and lots
02 — Payout
Cash or credit
Take the cash, or take more. Store credit is worth 25% extra on the same item, every time.
$20 cash
Same item, cash
$20
Digital payout the day we finish your evaluation. No waiting on a check.
25% more
Same item, store credit
$25
Credit lands in your customer account and applies to anything in the shop — games, cards, plush, media, even resurfacing.
That's $5 more on this one item. Credit never expires and it stacks. Sell a few boxes over a few months and spend it all at once.
03 — Process
How selling works
-
1
Send photos
Item names, condition, quantity. Phone photos are fine — just make sure labels and discs are readable.
-
2
Get an estimate
We reply with an initial cash and credit number, usually within 24 hours. Nothing is final until we see the items.
-
3
Ship or drop off
Mail it in with tracking, or bring it by in person. We confirm the moment your box lands.
-
4
Get paid
Digital cash payout, or store credit at the higher rate. Your call, after you see the final offer.
Start your submission
Takes about two minutes. No account needed to get an estimate.
Got it
We'll look it over and come back with a cash and credit number. Check your email, including spam.
Jay's Disc Restoration
We restore your discs. We don't just polish them.
Mail-in or local drop-off. Every disc is inspected first, resurfaced at the level it actually needs, then tested before it goes back in the sleeve.
No fix, no resurfacing charge
Disc type
Your estimate
$47.88
$3.99 × 12 discs
10–24 tier — $3.99 each.
Per disc
Standard CD / DVD$4.99
Heavy scratch$7.99
Blu-ray / game disc$6.99–$7.99
Bulk, per disc
10–24 discs$3.99 ea
25–49 discs$3.49 ea
50–99 discs$2.99 ea
100+ discs$2.49–$2.75 ea
Prepaid packs
5 discs$24.95
10 discs$39.90
25 discs$74.75
What you get
- Before and after photos of every disc
- Careful inspection before anything touches the surface
- Multiple resurfacing levels, matched to the damage
- Quality-control testing — we play it back
- Individual packaging on the return trip
- Tracking both directions
- Collector-friendly handling for sealed and rare discs
- Fast turnaround, not a two-week queue
Selling us discs?
We pay $5 cash per disc, or $4 in store credit — your choice, per batch.
Why sell here
Selling us your collection? We evaluate scratched discs for restoration before we set your trade-in value.
Most shops grade a scratched disc as damaged and price it that way. We check whether it can be restored first — and if it can, that goes into your offer. Same box of games, more money.